Monday, July 5, 2010

Idea Number 2

Idea Number 2:

Idea:
Sometimes, Authority Figures Can Be Right!

Explanation:
This is an annoyance to me. Let me start off by saying, I don't have much of a problem with authority. I am not sixteen anymore. I don't hate the man, because in more than one of my many jobs I have been the man.

It has become a trend in games for the hero to rebel against authority, or for authority figures to be completely inept. These authority figures tend to make monumentally stupid decisions, they tend to lack any and all shred of compassion, and they tend to be arrogant to the point of utter blindness.

This is not realistic.

People don't become authority figures if they don't know what they are doing. Unless they are producers anyway. (kidding!) Seriously though, if your authority figure is some wise general with forty years of military experience who supposedly rose in the ranks by placing the interests of his soldiers first, then why in the heck is he acting like a selfish eight year old with the tactical knowledge of a first grader.

Seriously, when the player characters approach the wise general after just having defeated a giant monster in the middle of the city that attacked the parade why is it the general is almost always responding with lines like: "Impossible! The dark lords cannot have returned! This was an isolated incident! The tomb of the dark lords is only like 5 minutes away, I'm not even going to send scouts to check!"

What?!? Why?! If a monster attacks my town, and some kid, who just beat up said monster, claims it is the dark lord's return I'm going to at least send an intern to go look. I mean seriously, that is why you have interns. To do the things that are menial and generally not important.

When your intern gets back gibbering about how there are monsters outside of town and in the woods and his psyche has been shattered then you know that you have a problem. Instead of that however the most common response is to dismiss the guys who just saved the lives of dozens of citizens and pretend that everything is just fine until inevitably the city is overrun by monsters.

Sure, I get it, the reason this convention is used is to explain the reason why the military doesn't handle the problem and to create a situation where the player has to do so. This is all well and good. Though you can manage this without making your characters complete idiots.

You can use all kinds of other deus ex machina to create a situation why the player has to do it without breaking suspension of disbelief by having unrealistic characters. And that, for today, is idea two.

Tune in tomorrow!

No comments:

Post a Comment