Tuesday, July 6, 2010

Idea Number 3

Idea Number 3:
Gender Roles

Explanation:
In this day and age of political correctness even the most logical application of anything that could be considered gender, racial, or any other kind of bias or the like is seen as being a serious and major no-no. This is the same in games as it is in movies and any other entertainment medium. I am reminded of a comment that Kevin Smith once made where, in his movie Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back, a rated R comedy, he was fined over $10,000.00 simply because he had a character say, "You are so gay." to another.

This is beginning to bleed off into video games and in my opinion this is incredibly stupid. To illustrate this point I will reference a game that I recently played. This was a spy game, and I love spy games, even more importantly this game had some RPG elements in it. One was the ability to play a female agent. At one point you have to sneak into the manor house of this rich drug lord type bad guy and photograph some documents.

Pretty standard stuff.

While playing as the male character I posed as a waiter and I stealthily made my way inside, photographed the plans and made my way out. While I was in there I noticed that there was a bevy of beautiful women near the pool and the dossier specifically said that he often throws parties and has an eye for the ladies.

I instantly thought, "When I play through as a female character I'll probably get in that way."

So, after beating the game, and starting it again, I chose a female character. Imagine my shock and surprise when every single mission was the exact same and only a couple words of dialogue were changed. Now, I didn't mind this for like, an assassination mission or something, I didn't mind this for a "pick up the drop" mission, but for the drug lord mission? It didn't make any sense.

That wasn't the only mission that should have had an alternate method of getting in either. There is a mission to a club later that had female dancers where you had to eavesdrop on a conversation, as a male character I disguised myself as a bouncer, which fit, all of the bouncers in the club were male. As a female character I... Still had to disguise myself as a bouncer... Which made me stick out like a sore thumb but nobody seemed to notice.

Okay, it is a modern game, women can do anything men can do, we know. However come on... That was silly, not only did it hurt replay value, but it literally hurt the verisimilitude of the game itself.

This isn't just something in modern games either. Games that take place in medieval times do this all the time too. The point is there isn't anything wrong with characters in games acting in accordance with gender roles.

The worst I have ever seen this was in a "historical" role playing game. They had the stereotypical tough-as-nails female character talk smack to the evil lord. My instant response on seeing the scene was, "Oh well... She's dead."

However, he didn't do anything, he sat there and took it... If your game is going to be historical... THEN BE HISTORICAL...

This doesn't mean that you should make every female character in your game some doe eyed delicate maiden who can't defend herself, but once in a while it is okay, it is doubly okay if the character is only impersonating that kind of character in order to achieve a specific goal!

Basically, I am not a fan of political correctness. I am not a misogynist or a racist or anything like that but I also am not a fan of limiting choices and character design simply because someone might get offended.

See ya next time!

No comments:

Post a Comment