The purpose of this blog is simple.
My name is Henry Walsh and I am a Game Designer. No I never got to work on anything really big, just some casual and edutainment stuff. No I am not still in design (though I'd like to be) instead I became a teacher and I taught Game Design.
I feel like I still have a lot to offer so I decided, at the urging of a very good friend and mentor, to begin sharing this stuff with the world.
So, these are all opinions... Take them or leave them...
Idea Number 1:
Idea:
The Good Guys Can Be Proactive!
Explanation:
This one just bothers me. In every game I play the "Good Guy" is always on the defensive in the back story, while the "Bad Guy" is always on the offensive. This is especially prevalent in MMORPGs. Just look at Warhammer: Age of Reckoning or Star Wars: The Old Republic, in both games the "Good Guy" (Order in WAR and the Republic in TOR) are on the defensive in all of the pre-game hype.
This is a very bad idea, there is no point to it. What you end up with is making each side appealing to a specific type of player. Offensive players want to be the offensive side and defensive players want to be the defensive side.
Not only does that split the player base but this also simply is absurdly unrealistic. Wars are not fought in one way affairs. If you are going to have a story that depicts a war between "Good" and "Evil" or heck, even just "Side 1" and "Side 2" it makes no sense that Side 1 will always be on the offensive and Side 2 will always be on the defensive.
Wars are a series of offensives and counter-offensives. They are back and forth affairs. They are never simply proactive and reactive.
Another problem with this convention is that, from a narrative standpoint, the "Defensive Faction" feels ripped off, and rightly so. This is really pronounced with the hard core fans, because you have one side who is constantly beaten on and never fights back.
This is, what I call, the Karate Kid syndrome.
We see the underdog get picked on, beat up, and generally be ineffective. Usually right before the game launches we see them rally back for an offensive... But we never get to see the end result.
Imagine you are watching the Karate Kid, the original, with Mr. Miagi.
Now, you watch Daniel get beaten on by the people from the Cobra Kai Dojo. We see him get beaten up, we see him failing to be able to fight back, but then in steps Mr. Miagi who decides to teach him Karate... Even if he is teaching him Kung Fu, but that is beside the point...
Now, we watch the training beat, complete with the expected 80's training montage, and we see the Tournament begin... Daniel steps onto the mat, the Cobra Kai steps onto the mat and...
Then we turn the movie off.
Because in an MMORPG the story can never end. Meaning that we never see Daniel win. Not only that, but we never feel like the suffering of our chosen side was justified from a narrative standpoint. Then, due to game balance reasons, we are not stronger than our enemies either, meaning that there was no point really to the build up and our training montage.
Suggestion:
If you are going to show this kind of "Attacker" and "Defender" split in your MMORPG do it justice in your pre-launch hype. If you are going to paint one side as the underdog then before the game starts there needs to be some kind of vindication.
This is pretty easy to do actually.
Make sure that your launch cinematic depicts a major "Good Guy" victory out of the blue. Have them smash the big hyped up city of the bad guys, then in game have that city be destroyed, have the "bad guys" see their city crushed and think, "Holy crap! These guys can fight back!" because then it sets a whole new pecking order and makes it feel like both sides are on even ground.
Not only that but you are basically creating a mini-story revolving around the pre-game hype that keeps people entertained while you create the game for them.
Anyway, those are my opinions! Check back tomorrow for more of my 1001 Game Ideas blog!
Henry Walsh, signing off.
No comments:
Post a Comment